European flag
November 2022

Strategic crisis management in the EU

Improving crisis management has become an essential issue for protecting and enhancing present and future wellbeing in the EU and globally.

The European Union is confronted with an increasing number of crises with growing complexity, causing suffering and other devastating consequences. In response to this challenge, the SAM and the European Group on Ethics in Science and New Technologies are presenting policy recommendations to improve crisis management frameworks. 

Evidence review

The European Union is confronted with an increasing number of crises with growing complexity. Their effects can cascade and ripple to all parts of society, the economy, and the environment. The effects of such crises are not limited to specific geographical regions or sectors of society, and many crises continue indefinitely. Because they last, they overlap and amplify each other.

Decisions made during crises are not only urgent, but have long-lasting consequences. Therefore, strategic crisis management needs to be aligned with broader policy objectives. Using digital tools, guidance and standards can be set for strategic foresight and risk monitoring, to ensure that a longer-term perspective is integrated. Better data preparedness can ensure that information can be shared effectively while respecting privacy and security when a crisis hits. 

To address the growing complexity of crises, we need a vision that integrates both risk management and crisis management. Different activities and organisations also need to coordinate: responses on multiple geographical and temporal scales need to be aligned, rather than aiming at the one ‘right’ level. Here, the EU could play an important coordinating role. The EU can also play a role in training decision- and policy-makers to coordinate and manage crises.

Crises amplify existing inequalities, hitting the most vulnerable the hardest — and this can erode trust across society at exactly the time when trust is most needed. New technologies and forms of communication offer ways for citizens to be engaged and empowered. Involving civil society can bring many advantages, producing a better informed, tailored, and localised response.

Scientific opinion

From crisis to crisis, the role of the EU has increased. How can the EU improve its strategic crisis management for the future? Based on the latest scientific evidence, the Group of Chief Scientific Advisors recommends that existing and future legislation and instruments should  be integrated in a framework that is capable of dealing with increasingly systemic and large-scale crises in a structural way.

A more systemic approach to crisis management should encompass all phases, from preparedness to response and recovery. Synergies should be considered between crisis mitigation measures. The unintended consequences of these measures should also be predicted (as far as possible) and addressed, assessing their impact on society in the longer term.

Preparedness efforts, from stockpiling to training, from contingency planning to exercises and simulations, should be based on lessons learned from past crises and on improved anticipation capacity. It is vital to prepare not only for the direct physical impacts, but also for indirect impacts that may occur far away from where the crisis originated, and for impacts on the functioning of societies as a whole, such as on trust, financial systems, and the mental health of citizens.

It is impossible to fully identify risks and threats. Therefore, we need to build resilience to deal with the complex cascading, cross-border, cross-sector impacts of crises.

To increase the EU’s resilience, we must  collaborate closely with society to manage crises effectively; make critical infrastructures more resilient to cascading effects; make existing European financial instruments and resources more scalable, rapidly deployable, and efficient; and provide interoperable, high-quality data, and easy-to-communicate information for crisis management.

Statement on ethics

The European Group on Ethics in Science and New Technologies presents a statement entitled ‘Values in times of crisis’.

Crises can threaten the fundamental values of our society. Decisions must be taken fast and under great pressure, often in contexts of high uncertainty, without a robust evidence base and with little experience.

But European ethical values can also make an important contribution to strategic crisis management. Values play an important role in how we understand and make sense of crises. They influence how we frame the problems that strategic crisis management is supposed to address, and how we choose the instruments to do so.

The fundamental European value of solidarity is particularly relevant. When leaders appeal to solidarity during a crisis, it is often in a tokenistic way — for instance, to demand from people that they comply with measures or accept hardship. This can do more harm than good, especially when governments themselves are seen to act in ways that are detrimental to solidarity.

However, when solidarity is used as a way to decide who we prioritise and who we exclude, or on the ways we establish boundaries between ‘us’ and ‘others’, then it can help to make better, more ethical, and more sustainable decisions. Similarly, solidarity can be a guiding principle for overcoming crises and strengthening societal resilience. This is because it bridges individual and collective needs and interests in the deep awareness of human interdependence across borders, social groups, and other boundaries.

Scientific advice

Requested by

Delivery date

22 November 2022

Supports EU mission

Adaptation to climate change

Supports UN sustainable development goals

Climate action

Introductory video

Play Video

Resources

The Group of Chief Scientific Advisors respond to the request for advice from the European Commission.

Their policy recommendations are based on the best available scientific evidence.

Strategic crisis management scientific opinion
Bibliographic information
DOI
10.2777/517560
ISBN
9789276539476
Licence
Copyright
Cite as
European Commission, Directorate-General for Research and Innovation, (2022). Strategic crisis management in the EU : improving EU crisis prevention, preparedness, response and resilience, Publications Office of the European Union.
The Scientific Opinion is written jointly by the Group of Chief Scientific Advisors. Former Advisors (‘alumni’) may also contribute.
Portrait of Janusz Bujnicki

Janusz Bujnicki

Alumnus
Portrait of Pearl Dykstra

Pearl Dykstra

Alumnus
Portrait of Nicole Grobert

Nicole Grobert

Advisor
Portrait of Carina Keskitalo

Carina Keskitalo

Alumnus
Portrait of Éva Kondorosi

Éva Kondorosi

Advisor
Portrait of Maarja Kruusmaa

Maarja Kruusmaa

Advisor
Portrait of Eric Lambin

Eric Lambin

Advisor
Portrait of Alberto Melloni

Alberto Melloni

Advisor
Portrait of Nebojša Nakićenović

Nebojša Nakićenović

Advisor
Portrait of Eva Zažímalová

Eva Zažímalová

Advisor

News

24 July 2023
How to be ready for wildfires
An interview with Thomas Elmqvist, Professor of Stockholm University, Stockholm Resilience Centre and one of the world’s most cited scientists.
22 November 2022
Europe needs better, more strategic crisis management, according to independent scientific and ethics advisors
The European Union is dealing with an increasing number of complex, overlapping cross-border crises, such as the COVID-19 pandemic, climate change, and Russia's invasion of Ukraine.

Events

24 November 2023
International seminar on response diversity
In-person event
As we enter an era of unprecedented turbulence at the planetary level, we urgently need to rethink our crisis management theories, principles, and practices to be fit for purpose in the twenty-first century.
11 October 2023
GLOBE EU wakeup call #14
Online event
During this WakeUp Call, not only will we delve into the specific challenges of wildfire management in the EU, but also explore how the concept of response diversity can be interpreted and implemented in European policy.
22 June 2023
Crises and the importance of research: how prepared can we be?
In-person event with streaming
This symposium invites international experts to explore how research contributes to preparing for multiple entangled crises.
8 May 2023
Are we ready for the next cross-border health crisis?
Online event
What can be done to ensure that Europe is ready for the next pandemic or bioterrorism threat?
23 March 2023
Why do we need public trust in times of crisis?
In-person event with streaming
This event will particularly look into issues of trust between citizens and public institutions. It will discuss why trust in turbulent times of crisis is such an essential principle, how to build it and when, who we trust and why, and who we should trust.
20 March to 
22 March 2023
Second conference on the Ukraine crisis
Online event
The conference aims to mobilise the scientific community to critically examine the surge of protection and support efforts during the past year and assess ways forward for enhanced long-term support and post-conflict reconstruction.